Would you accept a re-constructed Tally Hall?

As you all know, the different members of Tally Hall have each gone their separate ways, but a few of them seem to still be into music like Rob, Andrew, and Bora which has been an honorary 5th member.

Let's say those three return and bring a new member or two as needed - would you consider them Tally Hall?

I know Miracle Musical is a similar-ish scenario but that seems to have been deliberately branded as its own separate thing.