Scared of picking a "too popular" name

My husband and I are expecting our first baby in January and thought we had our name. We had picked Olivia because it goes well with my husband's last name and I love all of the nickname potentials. I then made the mistake of looking up how popular the name is....and can't help but feel less enthusiastic for the name since finding out it's the most popular name for the last few years.

Is this a silly reason to go back to the drawing boards? Am I overthinking this? I would love some outside options.

I also like the name Petra but it doesnt have many nickname options besides "pet" which weirds me out. (My name doesn't lend itself to nicknames and I always wanted one as a kid lol).