Super duper disappointed on vetrimaran trying to justify these acts. He is trying to white wash the anti-social, inhumane act in the film? Angry rant ahead. Do not click if you haven't seen the film. Mods please dont delete this.
We were supposed to follow the moral compass of kumaresan and experience stuff from his point of view. First fail.
Everyone knows what kind of leader perumal is, even before seeing all the flashbacks. We never needed a extended super duper very long flashback of perumal. He is a commie, we already got it vetri.
Kumaresan belongs to E company. Pretty sure there are plenty of people at the base equipped with all weopons and stuff. And there are pretty sure A,B,C and D companies somewhere. And yet you trust random 5 constables to transfer a high value prisoner. Dumb move. And it didnt have proper reason. Even the reason behind is there is a mole in the base, literally no one could have extracted perumal from the base. No one. Its like you take him from the forest because thats perumal's strong hold, and end up transfering him to the same forest? Pretty dumb move as if there is no other place in tamil nadu. An ideal police force would have used all the power it has to secure the prisoner like perumal.
From viduthalai 1, we sense that its kumaresan narrating a story to his mother. And now he narrates what perumal said to him including entire flashback of vathiyar? Would have worked only if it was from kumaresan POV.
Dop velraj is a constable and pannaiyar? Very weak interms of casting.
Easily could have avoided manju warrier portions. The idea is to narrate only how perumal becomes an outlaw from a teacher. A simple narration. But starting from manju, every charecter is a filler charecter rather than development of actual plot happening in the forest.
They kill only capitalists aka pannaiyars. But suddenly they get into bomb business? And he witness the horrors of it while making the bomb and that would have made sense if they stopped the idea of making bombs then and there. But they dont. They still made the bombs. Actual ones and placed it under a railway bridge.
They kept an actual bomb as a warning? To show that they are serious? To whom? To people? To government? I never understood that part. You fight for the rights of people, yet you threaten to kill the same people by placing a bomb? And you blame the government for not noticing it? Manobala calls several people and they answer "indha maari call laan neraya varum, aana onnume irukkadhu, neenga velaya paarunga saar, illana thirumba train late aagum" is the kind of answer he gets. Because it happened several times, which probably because of makkal padai, they refuse to believe when it happened for real. If i were the guy on the phone, i would have done the same thing because i dont want to take heat because of a rumour again. Most dumbfuck moment is expecting nothing to wrong while placing a literal bomb under a bridge. And they cry about it too. Lmao.
Not to mention the lameass dubbing, DI, editing,etc., Even being shot on mountains, kanguva had a decent DI. But this film had a lame DI. And thats the difficulty he claims. Overall, first time seeing vetrimaaran as tholvi maaran.
We were supposed to follow the moral compass of kumaresan and experience stuff from his point of view. First fail.
Everyone knows what kind of leader perumal is, even before seeing all the flashbacks. We never needed a extended super duper very long flashback of perumal. He is a commie, we already got it vetri.
Kumaresan belongs to E company. Pretty sure there are plenty of people at the base equipped with all weopons and stuff. And there are pretty sure A,B,C and D companies somewhere. And yet you trust random 5 constables to transfer a high value prisoner. Dumb move. And it didnt have proper reason. Even the reason behind is there is a mole in the base, literally no one could have extracted perumal from the base. No one. Its like you take him from the forest because thats perumal's strong hold, and end up transfering him to the same forest? Pretty dumb move as if there is no other place in tamil nadu. An ideal police force would have used all the power it has to secure the prisoner like perumal.
From viduthalai 1, we sense that its kumaresan narrating a story to his mother. And now he narrates what perumal said to him including entire flashback of vathiyar? Would have worked only if it was from kumaresan POV.
Dop velraj is a constable and pannaiyar? Very weak interms of casting.
Easily could have avoided manju warrier portions. The idea is to narrate only how perumal becomes an outlaw from a teacher. A simple narration. But starting from manju, every charecter is a filler charecter rather than development of actual plot happening in the forest.
They kill only capitalists aka pannaiyars. But suddenly they get into bomb business? And he witness the horrors of it while making the bomb and that would have made sense if they stopped the idea of making bombs then and there. But they dont. They still made the bombs. Actual ones and placed it under a railway bridge.
They kept an actual bomb as a warning? To show that they are serious? To whom? To people? To government? I never understood that part. You fight for the rights of people, yet you threaten to kill the same people by placing a bomb? And you blame the government for not noticing it? Manobala calls several people and they answer "indha maari call laan neraya varum, aana onnume irukkadhu, neenga velaya paarunga saar, illana thirumba train late aagum" is the kind of answer he gets. Because it happened several times, which probably because of makkal padai, they refuse to believe when it happened for real. If i were the guy on the phone, i would have done the same thing because i dont want to take heat because of a rumour again. Most dumbfuck moment is expecting nothing to wrong while placing a literal bomb under a bridge. And they cry about it too. Lmao.
Not to mention the lameass dubbing, DI, editing,etc., Even being shot on mountains, kanguva had a decent DI. But this film had a lame DI. And thats the difficulty he claims. Overall, first time seeing vetrimaaran as tholvi maaran.