When you are juggling options, how do you determine who to give your time to?

I have a few people who are interested in me, and me them. I am struggling to decide who to give my time to. I feel connected to all of them, and have a great deal of openness in conversation with all of them. Some are more physically my type than others and we share more similar interests, but I’m trying to not let that influence my decision.

How can you tell if a connection is meant to be platonic or more?