NEED ADVICE: What should I do?

So I have a bachelor's (in liberal studies) which is an unrelated I.T. field. I also have CompTIA A+, Net+, Sec+ and LPI Linux Essentials.

With this being said, I'm at a crossroads of what to do. Here are my options where I try to finish in 6 months (1 semester):

  1. B.S. in I.T. at WGU (would only require 25% of classes since I'm transferring in 75% of the degree/certs)

  2. M.S. in I.T. Management at WGU (would require 10 classes)

Which is better career wise and for HR? The fact that I don't have a degree in I.T. is what's concerning me and I really feel like it's holding my resume back.

Again, I already have a Bachelor's (just not in the I.T. field).

Any suggestions?

Thanks everyone!