Can’t decide on a skin tint

Wanting to get a new skin tint, currently between ilia and YLS.

Tried rare beauty but meh.

I have combo skin but currently more dry because of winter 🥲

Also open to other recommendations besides ones listed above - TIA!!!!

Bonus if you lmk if you use a primer before hand ❤️

ETA/ I appreciate you all❤️ ciele isn’t available in Canada :( so I went with the yummy skin!!