Is OJ trash?

I've recently been seeing alot of people in CR yt shorts calling OJ a whale, and a trash/washed up player.

Is this true?

IIRC the dudes hit UC before and after the trophy road split, won several grand challenges, and beat all the 20 win challenges. Yeah the dude has spent alot of money on the game, but he seems far from a trash player to me. So why do people insist he's not good at the game? What does it take to be deemed a good player these days?